by contributor Matt Winkler
“Dad, remember when you told me that if a kid ever hits me,
that I have your permission to beat him into the ground?”
(I did say that.) My eyes flick over my son – no evidence of injury, slightly out of breath from the two mile bike ride, bathing suit still wet from the town pond. “Tell me what happened.” Like dads have been doing for millennia, I listen patiently to a tale of pre-teen roughhousing that crossed the line. Luckily, in this story, an alert lifeguard saw my son backhand his new pal in the cheek. She blew the whistle and sent him home. “OK, now that doesn’t sound to me like self defense. Right? If you could rewind back to that moment, what else might you have done?”
“Well, I did warn him, if he didn’t stop I was going to hit him.” I give Logan a few minutes to consider an alternative strategy – one that didn’t involve threats and ejection from the park. With effort, he recalls hearing something about consulting an adult or walking away as the recommended methods of avoiding violent confrontation.
“That’s right,” I confirm, supportively. “So, you messed up. You lost your temper. You were out of line. You’re human, you’re going to mess up. Now, you have to do the hardest thing a man has to do: admit you did something wrong, and try to make it right.” For some reason, I’m sure that I’m quoting John Wayne. I’m sure that all red-blooded American men have heard or given this speech at least once in their lives.
Despite his pleas to the contrary, I drive him back to the pond. Hopefully, such uncomfortable and immediate consequences will give him pause next time. Along the way, I coach him to accept responsibility like a man, without equivocating. Apologize, and promise that it won’t happen again. He sweats bullets during the short drive.
We meet the five-foot tall, sixteen-year-old lifeguard who kicked him out. She tells us that Logan’s pal, Aaron, was bleeding, restates the rules, admonishes Logan again, and passes the buck to her boss in terms of punishment. I hold Logan’s shoulder as he absorbs all this, and I nod to her that she’s doing a good job. I park Logan at the picnic table, and he is visibly shocked to learn that he drew blood. The boss isn’t around, and neither is Aaron, so we head home. Logan sends him a note on Facebook.
The next day, we return to talk with the Rec Park boss, who looks like a young middle-school teacher who does this as a summer job. He gives the story a level hearing and determines that Logan’s contrition is sincere. We head home, the hard part over. “Now, wasn’t it much better to face it and settle it, rather than avoid it and worry about it?” Logan nods, relieved. The whole thing has worked out so neatly, like some Brady Bunch episode. But still, I hope that Aaron’s parents (whom I’ve never met) aren’t filing a lawsuit.
The day after, Logan sees Aaron at the pond and apologizes. “It happens,” Aaron shrugs, brushing it off. And like billions of boys before them, they resume roughhousing.
Since “turning the other cheek” doesn’t work so well in the modern age, how do you teach your kids to deal with fighting?